Do you want to elevate your roasting skills to the next level? Having a roasting pan is a must-have kitchen tool for any chef. Not only can you roast meat and vegetables, but these versatile pans have various other uses.
With a wide range of styles and special features available, selecting the ideal roasting pan to meet your needs can be challenging. Consequently, we have undertaken a review of the best roasting pans currently available in the market, to help you find your perfect match.
The Best Roasting Pans Reviews
1. Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster with Rack – Best Roasting Pan for Outdoor Use
When it comes to camping, one of the best things is being able to roast your food over a campfire. However, it's crucial to select your cooking equipment wisely. It needs to be durable enough to withstand the heat of a campfire while also being lightweight and portable.
The Cuisinart Chef's Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster is an excellent option for outdoor cooking. This robust model is compatible with campfires, grills, and a variety of other heat sources. Its smooth and flat base makes it suitable for use on stovetops, and it conveniently fits on two-burner stoves.
But wait, there's more...
The incorporated large and sturdy rack can effortlessly support a twenty-pound turkey. Large pieces of meat are roasted evenly and faster than usual. Plus, the flat base of the pan is perfect for making gravies and sauces while roasting.
Measuring sixteen inches long, this roasting pan can hold a substantial amount of vegetables. Thinly sliced carrots, turnips, and other vegetables can roast in the bottom while your turkey roasts. The pan's depth is also ideal for baking lasagna and other delectable dishes.
Easy to grip...
One of the great things about this model is its remarkably sturdy handles. However, those with relatively large hands may find them a bit small. Nonetheless, their heat-resistant design eliminates the need for wearing thick and bulky oven mitts.
Pros
Cons
2. Calphalon Contemporary 16 Inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack – Most Durable Roasting Pan
Our next review in the best roasting pans is for those seeking a lifetime of dependable service.
If you have ever struggled with removing baked-on grease from a roasting rack, you know how challenging it can be. Fortunately, with the Calphalon Contemporary 16-Inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan, this will never be an issue. The V-shaped roasting rack that comes with the pan features a thick non-stick coating, making it easy to clean.
Other impressive features...
The roasting rack's size and shape allow air to circulate around the food, ensuring even and slightly quicker cooking. It can hold a massive 25-pound turkey, along with other food items.
Even when filled with food, lifting the roasting pan out of the oven is easy. The pan's ends have large loop handles for a secure grip, triple-riveted for extra stability, and designed to stay relatively cool.
Built to last...
This model has a robust construction and won't buckle or warp at high temperatures, backed up by a comprehensive lifetime warranty. With proper care and maintenance, this will likely be the last roasting rack you will ever need.
It's worth noting that the roasting rack is slightly smaller than the pan, allowing for some movement. However, this is unlikely to cause significant problems.
Pros
Cons
3. Granite Ware Large Covered Oval Roasting Pan – Best Oval Roasting Pan
Are you up for exploring something distinctive? The Granite Ware Large Covered Oval Roasting Pan boasts a one-of-a-kind blue finish and versatile design, making it stand out from the usual roasting pans. Its exceptional features are poised to provide it with a competitive edge.
But is it actually any good?
Constructed from blue steel, this roasting pan offers excellent heat distribution and retention. Its interior surface is naturally non-stick and porcelain-coated without any PFAs or PFEs. Despite weighing less than three pounds, this model is incredibly sturdy.
Interior dimensions are 15 inches in length, 10.75 inches in width, and 4.25 inches in depth, this roasting pan provides ample space to cook a 15-pound turkey or a generous serving of vegetables. The large side handles on the base make it effortless to remove from the oven.
We love the lid…
The included tightly fitting lid enhances the versatility of this model, allowing it to double as a casserole dish or a baking pan with ease. This makes it an excellent option for preparing various dishes, including shepherd's pie, baked pasta, roast potatoes, and more.
Thanks to its thick non-stick coating, cleaning this roasting pan is a breeze, whether by hand or in the dishwasher. Additionally, you need not worry about scratching the interior, as this model can withstand the use of metal and other types of utensils.
Slide away…
It is worth mentioning that the base of this roasting pan is relatively smooth, which can cause it to slide on glass cooktops. Nonetheless, this roasting pan is suitable for use with all heat sources, including induction cooktops, which is its most critical compatibility feature.
Pros
Cons
4. Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Rectangular Roaster – Best Rackless Roasting Pan
Who says baking trays have to be mundane and uninteresting? The Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Rectangular Roaster breaks the mold with its vibrant enameled exterior, making it an eye-catching addition to your kitchen. You can choose from a variety of colors, such as Cerise, Flame, Caribbean, Marseille, Oyster, and Meringue.
But is it just a pretty face?
The remarkable thing about this pan is its compatibility with all heat sources. Whether in the oven or on the stovetop, including conduction, this pan is up for the task, thanks to its enameled cast iron construction that ensures even and efficient heat distribution and retention.
Beyond roasting, this pan excels in searing, slow-cooking, and other cooking techniques, making it a versatile kitchen staple. It's an excellent choice for recipes that require braising, searing, and caramelization. Even when wearing thick oven mitts, the large side handles make it effortless to lift the pan out of the oven.
Outstanding interior…
The pan's interior is made of non-reactive, sand-colored enamel that is naturally non-stick, allowing food to release smoothly and evenly. This feature also makes hand-cleaning the pan quick and effortless.
The only minor drawback is that some may prefer a roasting rack, which this model lacks. As a result, chicken and turkey will cook in their own juices, which can enhance their flavor. However, if you need a rack, it's easy to find a compatible one.
Pros
Cons
5. Anolon Triply Clad Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack – Best Extra Large Roasting Pan
The Anolon Triply Clad Stainless Steel Roasting Pan boasts an elegant appearance with its polished stainless steel and tri-ply construction. It incorporates an aluminum core that facilitates rapid and uniform heating of both the pan and accompanying rack.
This roasting pan is capable of withstanding high temperatures of up to 500°F without warping. The rack provides secure and comfortable support for chickens and turkeys during roasting, while the option to remove it enables the user to cook other dishes with ease.
Bigger is better…
If you're cooking for a large group of people, this twenty-inch-long roasting pan is the perfect choice. It's particularly well-suited for preparing your Thanksgiving turkey or Christmas goose. Additionally, when placed across two large burners, the pan heats up evenly on the stove top.
Any downsides?
Despite its exceptional features, one minor drawback of this roasting pan is its heavy and bulky design, weighing just over ten pounds, making it one of the heaviest in its class. As a result, it may be difficult to lift in and out of the oven.
Thankfully, the pan's large handles on either side, as well as those on the rack, provide a firm grip, mitigating any potential difficulty. Furthermore, the non-stick coating of the roasting rack makes cleaning quick and effortless. Finally, this product comes with a comprehensive lifetime warranty as an added benefit.
Pros
Cons
6. Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan with Rack – Best Roasting Pan with U Rack
For those in search of a versatile roasting pan, the Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan is an excellent choice. It features a removable U-rack, enabling you to prepare a variety of dishes with ease and enjoyment.
Time to get roasting…
The U-rack featured in this roasting pan is both sizeable and robust enough to accommodate a 24-pound turkey. Its elevated structure ensures that air circulates freely, resulting in quick and uniform cooking of your bird. Any extra juices are collected in the flat base of the roasting pan.
By detaching the roasting rack, you can utilize the pan to cook vast quantities of potatoes, vegetables, and even lasagna. The pan's thickness and sturdiness enable it to cook various food items promptly. Moreover, the large stainless steel handles located at the end are firmly riveted, providing added stability.
Cleaning up…
The interior of the roasting pan features a PFOA-free non-stick coating, making it effortless to clean manually. Alternatively, for maximum convenience, both the roasting tray and rack are dishwasher safe.
The thick stainless steel wires of the roasting rack are set at a suitable distance, ensuring efficient airflow and allowing for quick and easy cleaning with a damp cloth post-roasting.
Built to last…
This sizable and adaptable roasting pan is challenging to fault, and it even includes a full lifetime guarantee, providing additional assurance. However, please ensure that you have enough storage capacity in your kitchen for this formidable model.
Pros
Cons
7. Mr Rudolf 17 in Roasting Pan with Lid and Rack – Best Roasting Pan for Drip Free Pouring
The Mr Rudolf 17 inch Roasting Pan features an exquisite 18/10 mirror finish, which not only adds to its aesthetic appeal but also makes cleaning a breeze. Even after repeated washing cycles in the dishwasher, the finish remains smooth and lustrous.
This model is perfect for preparing massive meals and serving large gatherings. It boasts a capacity of up to twelve quarts of soup or stew, making it a versatile addition to any kitchen. Additionally, the reinforced drip-free pouring rims reduce spillage when using this robust model.
Keeping a lid on things…
The inclusion of a matching lid with this roasting pan enhances its versatility. The lid's ability to trap in heat and moisture ensures that your food stays moist and flavorful. Additionally, the deep lid can double as a separate roasting or baking pan.
The pan is equipped with solid stainless steel handles that are welded onto its sides, matching those on the lid. This design provides a secure grip, even when the lid is in place. You can comfortably hold both pairs of handles simultaneously, and the handles are engineered to remain cool to the touch.
Relatively short warranty, though…
Although the Mr Rudolf 17 inch Roasting Pan comes with only a one-year warranty, you can receive an extended limited lifetime warranty by registering the product. This extra warranty provides peace of mind and reinforces the durability of this roasting pan.
Pros
Cons
8. Viking Culinary 3-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan – Best Roasting Pan for Entertaining
The last product featured in our top roasting pans review is designed with regular entertainers in mind. As any seasoned host knows, it's important to select kitchen equipment that can accommodate large quantities of food when entertaining guests.
Large capacity…
Rest assured that the Viking Culinary Stainless Steel Roasting Pan will exceed your expectations. With a generous capacity of up to twenty pounds, this pan can effortlessly accommodate large turkeys and even serve as a handy tray for presenting your culinary creations.
Crafted from triple-ply stainless steel, this pan boasts exceptional durability and strength. The material's quick heating and even heat distribution capabilities ensure consistently excellent results. Additionally, this roasting pan can be conveniently stored in the refrigerator to preserve leftovers.
Turning up the heat…
You can roast with confidence at high temperatures with this model. It can withstand oven temperatures of up to 600°F and is also suitable for use with all other heat sources. If you require a sizable pan that's compatible with induction cooktops, this model is a perfect fit.
The pan and roasting rack are both equipped with generously sized handles for a secure grip. The roasting pan handles are positioned relatively high, allowing for effortless lifting of the rack to serve your roasted meats and other delectable dishes.
Simple to clean…
The V-shaped roasting rack comes with a thick non-stick coating, which simplifies the cleaning process. However, it's worth noting that the rack is not suitable for use in dishwashers. On the bright side, the roasting pan itself is dishwasher safe and can be cleaned with ease.
Pros
Cons
Best Roasting Pans Buying Guide
If you believed that all roasting pans were created equal, it's time to reconsider. This indispensable piece of kitchenware can boast a plethora of diverse features that significantly impact its overall performance and practicality. Here are some of the essential factors to contemplate when shopping for the optimal roasting pan for your needs.
Size Matters
Primarily, determining the ideal size of your roasting pan is crucial. It depends on the type of food you intend to prepare and the number of people you usually cook for. While smaller roasting pans are more convenient to store, they may not be adequate if you frequently entertain guests.
The Shape
Typically, roasting pans come in a rectangular shape, providing a larger cooking surface area compared to oval pans. Nevertheless, oval roasting pans are often favored for their aesthetic appeal, and there are still plenty of larger models available on the market.
The Materials
Roasting pans can be manufactured from a variety of materials, including stainless steel, carbon steel, and enameled cast iron. Each material offers its unique advantages and disadvantages, which should be carefully considered.
Stainless steel is highly durable and boasts excellent heat conductivity, making it ideal for use in both the oven and on a stovetop. Nonetheless, stubborn grease and grime may be challenging to remove from stainless steel surfaces.
Compared to other materials?
While carbon steel pans are not as prevalent, they excel at retaining heat and can be used with most heat sources. However, pure carbon steel roasting pans tend to be relatively heavy.
Enameled cast iron roasting pans feature a sturdy natural non-stick coating, making them effortless to clean. Nevertheless, it is crucial to verify that they possess large handles since they can also be relatively heavy. Alternatively, a stainless steel roasting pan with a durable non-stick coating may be the best option.
The Weight
The dimensions and materials utilized in constructing the roasting pan will impact its weight. It is critical to ensure that the roasting pan is robust and sturdy, particularly when filled with food. However, it should not be so weighty that you have difficulty removing it from the oven.
The Handles
It is highly recommended to ensure that the roasting pan has adequately sized handles that offer a secure grip. The handles should be firmly attached to the pan via rivets to ensure ample stability. Additionally, it is preferable for the handles to remain cool to the touch.
Versatility
If you are an avid cook, you will surely appreciate a highly versatile roasting pan that can be utilized in numerous ways. With a top-of-the-line model, it becomes feasible to prepare various types of dishes and cook with different heat sources.
Ease of Cleaning
Removing burnt-on grease from a roasting pan can be a daunting and time-consuming task. It is therefore advisable to ensure that your roasting pan and rack are equipped with a durable non-stick coating. Additionally, opting for a dishwasher safe model can provide added convenience.
Durability
After selecting the ideal roasting pan, you would naturally want it to endure for as long as possible. Consequently, it is prudent to examine the type of warranty offered with the roasting pan. Premium models should ideally feature a lifetime warranty, providing additional reassurance.
So, Which of The Best Roasting Pans Should You Go For?
Cuisinart is renowned for producing top-quality and versatile cookware and bakeware. The...
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster with Rack
...is a perfect addition to their product line.
This roasting pan features a robust tri-ply, fully clad construction that ensures even heat distribution. The sturdy roasting rack can effortlessly accommodate a 20lb turkey. Additionally, this versatile model can be utilized for making gravy, braising, and deglazing a variety of foods.
Enjoy your roasting experience with this excellent roasting pan!
